Have a tendency to when times are given, he’s considering having 24 hours of few days one really does perhaps not match thereupon big date whilst inside the real records. One example takes place in Harry Potter in addition to Prisoner from Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney describes sixteen October once the Monday, even when 16 Oct 1993 was a monday.
It will be possible, however impractical, one to Fudge might be talking about a faraway predecessor, since Thatcher took work environment before Fudge purportedly turned into Minister to possess Miracle
There are even contradictions from inside the instructions of this type. Instance, during the Harry Potter and also the Cup out-of Fire, both step one Sep and you will 2 September are supplied since Mondays and you will, for the Harry Potter therefore the Prisoner out of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s trial is determined on 20 April, but cautious parsing of your text message demonstrates that it could provides took place zero after than February.
Along with, into the Harry Potter as well as the Cup out of Flames they do say that Winners were picked to your Saturday 31 Oct, however, 31 Oct is a friday for the 1994. not, it absolutely was after reported that twenty two November is actually a tuesday, that it was in 1994.
In the chapter 7 out-of Quidditch From the Years, they state that the first Quidditch Community Cup happened during the 1473. When your tournament try held every number of years, which problems toward report into the Cup off Flame that the 1994 Community Mug was the fresh new 422nd. When the Quidditch From Many years is great, the fresh new 422nd Quidditch Community Cup manage in fact belong the season 3161, in case Cup from Fire is great, the first Globe Mug was stored from inside the 306.
As the show, depending on the timeline produced by the latest Chamber off Gifts site, is set regarding the nineties, the new collection tend to looks as if it’s devote the fresh new late nineties so you’re able to middle-2000s, around concurrent to the book of your guides. Into the Harry Potter in addition to 50 % of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a male pronoun to mention into the “predecessor” of Finest Minister of your own British. Depending on the above timeline, this would take place in summer time of 1996, if the Prime Minister try John Significant, whose immediate ancestor was a lady (‘s the reason basic interviewing Fudge, the ebook says this new election, but Biggest was not initial elected and just got more shortly after Thatcher retired.
(In the event one can possibly think a situation in which Fudge was delegated of the Minister having Secret to meet on Perfect Minister as he, Fudge, was in an inferior work environment.) Simultaneously, the identity and history of the prime Minister depicted appears to a whole lot more closely meets that of Tony Blair than simply out-of John Significant. A post on Each day Post notes you to Rowling was intimate towards after that-Chancellor of your Exchequer Gordon Brown (usually regarded as a competition in order to Blair’s management of your Work Party, just who been successful your and you can turned Primary Minister), and therefore she could have been attempting to show Blair’s worst side. In case the books was basically devote connect with publication big date out of Philosopher’s Stone, up coming this experience create take place in 2002 (once Blair turned into Primary Minister).
An identical condition involves Nicolas Flamel, who had been said to be 665 in the course of the fresh first publication, however, Nicolas Flamel was a real historic profile and you may won’t have reached you to many years until 1996, within the go out the original publication are published. The rebuttal because of it is that the go out the brand new “real” Nicolas Flamel was born cannot correspond with the latest Nicolas Flamel out-of Harry Potter.
Other condition can be obtained off Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure because Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s intended in the series that Hagrid obtained you to definitely condition contained in this a couple of years regarding their expulsion out of school inside the 1942. However in one to world out of Harry Potter and Cup regarding Fire, Molly Weasley reminisces on Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently convergence with Molly’s ages in school, it seems unlikely one she remembers an earlier gamekeeper. Although not, it will be easy you to Hagrid did not become a great gamekeeper instantaneously shortly after are expelled, but alternatively already been since the Ogg’s assistant. This will be possible because whenever Harry thinks he tend to become expelled to possess flying towards broomstick versus consent inside the first 12 months, the guy wonders if he would be allowed to stay on because Hagrid’s assistant.